A condition grade describes two different things: how worn the appearance is and whether the item works. Cosmetic flaws (scratches, a broken case, yellowed plastic) drop you a step within used. Functional flaws (a disc that won't read, a save that won't hold, a stick that moves on its own) change the category.
When you read a listing, there's only one right question: what was tested.
The most common labels and what they mean
The names vary from seller to seller, but the scale is usually this.
- New: never used and complete, even without the cellophane (a warehouse leftover, for example).
- New, sealed: factory seal intact. You can't see the contents, so what matters is that the seal is really a factory one.
- Used, very good condition: works with no reservations, minimal or no signs of use.
- Used, good condition: works with no reservations, obvious signs of use (scratches that don't affect reading, a cracked case).
- Used with defects: partly works and the defect is stated, for example a game that starts but doesn't save.
- Faulty or for parts: doesn't work, or nobody managed to make it work. You buy it for the pieces.
The point to grasp: «good condition» describes an item that works like one in very good condition, but has lived a bit. An item that half works sits lower, among those with defects.
Cosmetic or functional
A cosmetic flaw shows. A functional flaw you find out when you switch on.
- Cosmetic: surface scratches, yellowed plastic, cracked case, faded cover, rental sticker.
- Functional: read errors, a save that won't hold, an unresponsive controller port, stick drift, shutdowns after a while of play.
The first lowers the price, the second changes the category. For someone who wants to play, a cartridge with a pen-written label that plays is worth more than a pristine one that doesn't save.
Discs: which scratches matter
Direction matters more than quantity. Radial scratches, from the centre to the edge, touch many tracks for a very short stretch, and the error correction on optical discs usually recovers them. Circular scratches follow the track and ruin a long, continuous run of data: those are the ones that send the drive into error.
Then depth matters. If your fingernail catches, the scratch is deep and polishing by hand won't be enough.
Look at the printed side too. On a CD the reflective layer sits just under the label, protected by a thin lacquer: a scratch on the artwork can be worse than one on the reading side. On a DVD the data layer is in the middle of the disc and better protected.
Held up to the light, bright pinpricks are tiny holes in the reflective layer and can't be repaired. Cracks starting from the centre hole tend to widen.
If you're testing a console, don't use the first disc that comes to hand. On the PlayStation 2 try a game with a blue underside (it's a CD) and one with a silver underside (it's a DVD): a worn drive may read one and not the other.
Cartridges: contacts, shell, battery
On retro gaming cartridges there are three things to look at.
Contacts. If they're dull, dark or have green traces, they're oxidised. Clean them with isopropyl alcohol and a cotton bud, until the cotton comes away clean. Avoid the pencil eraser: it's abrasive, wears the plating and leaves residue.
Label and shell. Water marks, rental stickers, writing, lifted corners. They also help you spot reproductions: grainy print, over-saturated colours, cross-head screws where Nintendo cartridges normally use a security screw.
Battery. Many cartridges that save your progress have a soldered coin cell inside that keeps the memory alive. On a game from the nineties it may be flat or close to the end. On Pokémon Gold, Silver and Crystal the same battery also runs the internal clock.
The test is simple: save, switch off, leave the cartridge out for a few hours (a day is better), switch on again. Not all cartridges have a battery: several games save to memory that doesn't need one. A cartridge that plays but doesn't save has a defect and should be described that way.
Case, cover, manual
The case is a consumable: PlayStation jewel cases crack at the hinges, the centre hubs lose their grip. It can be replaced, so it weighs little on the grade, but it should be declared. The exception is cases with the platform logo moulded into the plastic: a generic one in its place is noticeable.
The cover, on the other hand, matters. Check whether it's original or reprinted: hand-cut edges, flat colours, blurry barcode, paper that's too glossy. On PlayStation 1 games, check that both the booklet (which acts as the cover) and the rear inlay are there. For the manual, what counts is presence, complete pages and no writing.
«Loose» means just the disc or cartridge. «Complete» on its own means nothing: what counts is the list of what's inside.
And cellophane can be redone. A factory seal has regular folds and clean welds. Loose cellophane with bubbles or uneven welds suggests rewrapping.
Consoles and controllers: what to test
On a console, switching on is not a test: the menu loads even on machines that give out under load. The serious minimum:
- Boot and at least half an hour of real play, not just the menu.
- Drive tested with several discs, including dual-layer ones where they exist.
- All controller ports, one by one.
- Memory card slot, USB and video output, with the cable that will be shipped.
- Fan and temperature: a console that shuts off on its own after a while has a fault.
- Battery compartment, where there is one: corrosion on the contacts is visible to the eye.
On controllers, drift is tested on a calibration or test screen: you leave the stick still and watch whether the input moves on its own. It usually comes from wear and tends to get worse.
The Nintendo 64 stick works differently (it reads position with optical sensors), so it doesn't have that kind of drift. But the plastic mechanism wears: the stick gets loose and loses precision, and you feel it turning it by hand.
Yellowing of light plastic is cosmetic: it comes from light and heat and doesn't touch the electronics. It can be lightened with hydrogen peroxide treatments, but the yellow can come back and treated plastic can become more brittle.
What a serious listing should say
«Tested» on its own is worthless. What counts is what follows the word. A serious listing says:
- what you get, piece by piece, not just «complete»;
- how far the test went (started and played are different things);
- whether the save was verified, on games that save;
- region and edition, because a game from another region may not start on an unmodified console;
- the defects, split into cosmetic and functional;
- whether the item wasn't tested, and why.
«Untested» is an honest statement, if the price reflects it. «Working» without saying how it was checked is the real warning sign.
With us, every used product is checked, cleaned and tested to make sure it works before shipping. If you're not completely satisfied, you have 30 days to return it and get a refund: the details are in the refund policy. If you're after pieces to repair or strip for parts, take a look at the Spare Parts & Repairers section.
Frequently asked questions
What's the difference between «very good condition» and «good condition»?
On the most widespread scale, only cosmetic: neither admits functional defects. «Very good» means minimal or no signs of use. «Good» means obvious signs, for example scratches that don't affect reading or a cracked case.
Does a scratched disc still work?
It depends on direction and depth, not the number of scratches. Radial ones are usually recovered by error correction, circular ones are the most dangerous. If your fingernail catches, the scratch is deep.
How do I tell if a cartridge's battery is flat?
Save, switch off, leave the cartridge out for a few hours and switch on again. If the save is gone, the battery needs changing. It only applies to cartridges that use a battery for the memory.
Is it worth buying a piece «for parts»?
Only if you need a specific component: shell, drive, connectors, board. It's sold as not working and should be judged by what you can salvage, not by hoping it switches on.