How to spot a counterfeit game or console

Cartuccia Pokémon Silberne Edition per Game Boy, versione tedesca con codice DMG-AAXD-NOE sull'etichetta

A fake is spotted from production details, not from the game. On a cartridge, look at screws, plastic, label and circuit board. On a disc, look at the printed side and the ring near the hole. On the packaging, look at print, codes and barcode.

One sign on its own isn't enough. Two or three together are a diagnosis.

Cartridges

  • The screws. Nintendo cartridges for NES, Super Nintendo, Nintendo 64, Game Boy and Game Boy Color normally use a security screw (the so-called 3.8 mm gamebit). Game Boy Advance ones use a tri-wing screw, with three points. DS, 3DS and Switch cards have no screws. A cross-head screw on its own isn't proof, but it points to a replaced shell or a copy.
  • The plastic. An original shell has uniform colour and the two halves fit together without a step. Copies often have shinier plastic or plastic that feels different, burrs at the edges, uneven seams.
  • The codes. Original cartridges carry the Nintendo mark and the model code, for example AGB-002 on Game Boy Advance cartridges and NTR-005 on DS cards. The game code on the label follows the system prefix: DMG and CGB for Game Boy and Game Boy Color, AGB for Game Boy Advance, NUS for Nintendo 64, NTR for DS, CTR for 3DS. A missing or muddled code, or one with another system's prefix, is a strong signal.
  • The label. The original is printed sharp, with solid colours and edges that follow the recess. The copy shows grainy text, visible halftone, shifted colours, a crooked label or one smaller than the recess.
  • The circuit board. If you can see the inside, even in a photo, the original has a board with the manufacturer's mark and code. The copy often has a generic board, reprogrammable chips and hand-soldered joints.

Then there's the usage test. Many copies don't save or lose the data when switched off. A cartridge sold as a single game that shows a multi-game menu at start-up is a copy. This applies across retro gaming.

Discs

  • Printed side. A pressed disc has the artwork printed directly on the disc: sharp tiny text, no thickness to the touch. A glued paper label or an inkjet print points to a burned disc.
  • Ring near the hole. A pressed disc has production codes engraved on it, which on games usually include the title code (for example an SLES code on a European PlayStation game). IFPI codes alone aren't proof, because they also appear on blank discs. The rest is what counts: a burned disc shows the blank media's codes, not the game's.
  • Colour of the data side. Original PlayStation 1 games have a black data side, with few exceptions. A silver or purplish PS1 disc is suspect. The reverse doesn't hold: blank CDs with a black underside exist. PS2 games on CD have a blue side, those on DVD are silver. A burned disc often changes colour when moved in the light and shows the edge of the written area.
  • Product code. The same code must appear on the disc and on the packaging. PlayStation uses codes like SLES and SCES for European PS1 and PS2 games, SLUS for American ones, BLES and BCES for European PS3 ones. Nintendo uses DOL for GameCube, RVL for Wii, WUP for Wii U. If the codes don't match, the disc isn't the one that belongs to that packaging. In multi-disc games each disc has a variant of the code.

Packaging and the SIAE sticker

  • Print. An original cover is offset printed, with a very fine halftone. A home reprint shows inkjet dots, blacks that drift to brown, deformed logos, imprecise cutting.
  • Barcode. It must be consistent with the product. The same code on different titles, or covered by a generic sticker, is a serious signal.
  • SIAE sticker. Many editions distributed in Italy carry the SIAE mark, a holographic one. A flat sticker with no holographic effect is suspect. Its absence, on the other hand, proves nothing: imported copies don't have it, and not all Italian editions carry it.

Consoles and accessories

Outright fakes are rare among consoles and mostly concern clones. The more common problem is non-original shells and modified consoles sold as untouched originals.

  • Serial and model. The label under the console must be legible and consistent with the model. Some prefixes: SCPH for PS1 and PS2, CECH for PS3, CUH for PS4, CFI for PS5, NUS for Nintendo 64, DOL for GameCube, RVL for Wii, WUP for Wii U, HAC for Switch. If there's a box, the serials must match.
  • Aftermarket shells. Very common on Game Boy and Game Boy Advance: colours that were never released officially, text and logos that differ from the original or are missing, a missing serial label, screws that differ from the originals. It isn't a fake in the strict sense, but it should be declared, like a replaced screen.
  • Modified software. Check the system version in the settings and look for applications outside the official menu, like the Homebrew Channel on Wii. On PS2 a memory card that opens an alternative menu at start-up indicates a modification. A modified console isn't a fake, but it must be declared.

Among accessories the classic trick is selling a compatible one as an original. Original controllers carry a mark, a model code and a serial (for example CUH-ZCT1 or CUH-ZCT2 on the DualShock 4), but the best copies copy those too: look at the finish, weight and quality of the plastic.

On PS2 memory cards, capacity counts: official Sony ones are 8 MB, so one marked «64 MB» isn't Sony. On power supplies don't economise: a counterfeit one can damage the console.

Rules before you pay

  1. The price is the first clue. A rare title at a fraction of its value has a reason.
  2. Ask for photos of the exact piece. No catalogue images: front, back, data side or back of the cartridge, serial, inside of the case.
  3. Ask for a photo with a handwritten note and the date. Whoever has the piece sends it straight away.
  4. Ask whether it was tested and on which console. «Working» without saying on what isn't an answer.
  5. Read the product listing. It must say what you get, the real condition and the defects.

If you've already bought a fake

Don't resell it as an original. Document everything: photos of the piece, screenshots of the listing, the receipt. Open the dispute on the platform where you bought, within the time limits of its protection programme.

If you bought from a professional seller, as a consumer you have the legal guarantee of conformity and, for distance purchases, normally 14 days to withdraw.

If you bought from us, our authenticity guarantee applies. If you think the piece isn't original, write to us within 30 days of delivery with photos. If we got it wrong, we refund everything, return costs are on us and you get €10 credit on your next order.

Frequently asked questions

How do I tell if a Nintendo cartridge is original?

Look at several things together: the screw, the codes on the shell and the label, the print quality and, if you can, the circuit board. One odd detail needs a closer look, two or three together are a clear signal.

How do I tell a pressed disc from a burned one?

Look at the printed side and the ring near the hole. A pressed disc has the artwork printed on the disc and the game's codes engraved near the hole. A burned one carries the blank media's codes, often has a paper label and changes colour when moved in the light.

Is a game without a SIAE sticker fake?

No. Imported copies don't have it and not all Italian editions carry it. The sticker works the other way round: if it's there but flat and with no holographic effect, it's suspect.

What are «reproduction» cartridges?

Unauthorised copies of commercial games, built on new hardware. Whoever sells them as originals deceives the buyer, and even when declared they don't have the value of an original. Homebrew games released on cartridge by their own authors are a different case.